Mattoon Police arrested Shay A. Margenthaler, 30 years of age, and Shelby L. Quillman, 27 years of age, both homeless in Mattoon, for the offense of Domestic Battery. The arrest occurred on 5/29/2018 at 10:23am in the 1500 block of Marshal Ave in Mattoon.
The charge alleges that on 5/29/18, and during a domestic argument near the intersection of 17th and Marshall in Mattoon, Mr. Margenthaler slapped and kicked Ms. Quillman. Charges also allege Ms. Quillman had pushed and scratched Mr. Margenthaler’s neck, arms and back. Both Mr. Margenthaler and Ms. Quillman were taken to the Coles County Jail.